とあるまさおの討論録(ディベートログ)

とあるまさおの討論録(ディベートログ)

まさおがディベートについて思ったことをつらつらと書いていきます。ご自身の意見等あれば是非コメントしていただきたいです。Twitter→@masaoopen

R35:ほぼ関西Pro-Amのmotion

こんちは、今回は関西Pro-Amで出したmotionを載っけておきます

 

本当は解説とか軽く載せようかと思ったんですがそれは次回の自分に回したいと思います・・・

 

ちなみにmotion考えたぼくと某鳥類さんが当日参加できなかったこともありinfo slide多めで解説つけてる感じです

 

R1

Info

Distrustful:
If you are distrustful of someone or something, you think that they are not honest, reliable, or safe.

 

Motion

THBT schools and parents should teach children to be distrustful towards adults

 

 

R2

Info

Community sentencing combines punishment with activities carried out in the community other than prison.
Requirements under community sentencing can include but not limited to following conditions;
・unpaid work for fixed amount of time (e.g. cleaning town for 200 hours within term of sentence)
・undertaking a particular programme to help change offenders' behaviour (e.g. alcohol /drug treatments, back to work programmes)
・regular report and communication to appointed person (e.g. social worker / state authority)
・spatial requirements (e.g. prohibiting access to certain place at certain time)
Community sentencing may or may not coincide with continuation of offenders' original residence / occupation.

 

Motion

THW abolish prison and introduce community sentencing as a mean to punish criminals.

 

 

R3

Info

The term integrated resort (IR) is used to describe a major resort property that includes a hotel with casino, together with convention facilities, entertainment shows, theme parks, luxury retail and fine dining.

 

Motion

TH, as a developing country, S creation of Integrated Resort in economically depressed areas

 

 

R4

Motion

THO organized religion

 

 

GF

Motion

THR dominant emphasis on the importance of 'logics' and 'rationality' in political/social discourse

 

 

ってかんじです!

ちなみにGFのmotionは「こんなnarrative / dominant emphasis今存在する?」って言われて「たしかにぃ」ってなりましたゴメンナサイ()